is a 1966 short story by the Japanese author Yukio Mishima. The work depicts the spirits of young officers who were executed by firing squad in the February 26 Incident and the kamikaze pilots who died trying to become Kamikaze typhoon in the Pacific War, both of whom are angry and curse Emperor Shà Âwa's declaration of humanity.
The story is structured like a of Noh, with two scenes and six acts, and features the poignant and sorrowful refrain that repeats, "Why has our Sumeragi become a human being?"
This politically charged work marked a turning point for Mishima in the 1960s, and served as a precursor to his later critical essays such as .
A draft of seven songs entitled which is considered a preliminary version of the songs featured in the "Voices of the Fallen Heroes", was discovered in 1999 at the and was made public in the commemorative exhibition catalogue. The phrase alludes to the ambiguous position of the officers involved in the February 26 Incident who were not enshrined at Yasukuni Shrine as .
This work first appeared in the June 1966 issue of the literary magazine Bungei, and was published as a collection of his works, Voices of the Fallen Heroes, by Kawade Shobo Shinsha on June 30 of the same year. This book also includes "Patriotism" and the play , and was compiled as the "February 26 Incident Trilogy."
Mishima was 11 years old when the February 26 Incident occurred. He stated that one of his motivations for writing "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" was that "with the failure of the February 26 Incident, some great God had died," and that when he traced his "desire to console the spirits of the true heroes who had long dominated me, to clear their disgrace, and to attempt to restore their dignity," he was inevitably troubled by the Emperor's declaration of humanity.
In writing this work, Mishima referred to the prison memoirs (Prison Diary and Action Record) of Asaichi Isobe, a young officer who was executed in the February 26 Incident, and The February 26 Incident (1957), written by , the older brother of , who participated in the incident.
Tsukasa Kono has recounted a visit to Mishima's home in Minamimagome, à Âta, Tokyo to discuss the causes of the failure of the February 26 Incident. When Kono said, "I think it ultimately comes down to clarifying the relationship with the Emperor," Mishima agreed, saying, "So that's what you think, too." And, when the young officers accused of being part of a rebel force resolved to commit seppuku, atoning for the crimes they had committed as the Emperor's children, and requested through a chamberlain that an imperial emissary be sent to assist them, Emperor Shà Âwa replied, "If they want to commit suicide, do so freely; an imperial emissary is out of the question for something like such persons." Regarding the Emperor's putting his personal feelings at the forefront, Mishima said to Kono, "This is not what a Japanese Emperor should do. It's sad."
Kono further asked Mishima, "If the officers had known what the Emperor had said, would they have died shouting 'Long live the Emperor'?" Mishima replied, tearfully and choked up, "Even if their lord had no virtues as a lord, and had not performed his duties as a lord. I believe those men were sure to shout long live the Emperor, whom they believed to be a god, in keeping with the code of the path of a vassal. But that incident was a tragedy for Japan."
After publishing "Voices of the Fallen Heroes," Mishima wrote in a letter to Tsukasa Kono, "I wrote this work with the intention of dedicating it to the souls of your younger brother and the other officers who took part in the February 26 Uprising. By the way, be that as it may, I cannot help but feel irritated by the satiation, stagnation, and lethargy of modern Japan. Is this just only my particular hysteria?"
And, in an interview from the magazine , he said, "The Kokutai, the national system, has collapsed since the Emperor made his Humanity Declaration. All the moral confusion of the postwar period stems from that," and he argued that this was an important issue related to the quesion of "love" mediated by the "Emperor" (God), which was born out of Japan's .
In a dialogue with Shun Akiyama in 1968, Mishima said that he was "saved" by writing "Voices of the Fallen Heroes."
The story is structured in two scenes and six acts, following the style of of Noh. The Jo-ha-kyà « are as follows.
The characters are;
The work is written in the form of the narrator, who attended the "Return to God Society" meeting presided over by Kimura Sensei, a recording "as faithfully as possible" what he saw and heard there. It describes how the spirits of rebel officers who died in the February 26 Incident in 1936 and Kamikaze Special Attack Force soldiers who died in the one after another possess and curse a young spiritual medium, Shigeo Kawasaki.
The repeated phrase uttered by the spiritsâÂÂ"Why has our Sumeragi become a human being?"âÂÂis directed at Emperor Shà Âwa. The "betrayed spirits" of the soldiers are saddened and indignant at the Emperor's behavior during the February 26 Incident and his subsequent "Declaration of Humanity" on January 1, 1946, after Japan's defeat, which turned him into a "human being," and the voices of these heroic spirits echo throughout in the Shinto shrine.
The story ends with Shigeo Kawasaki, a medium who has absorbed the power of a spirit with a strong grudge, taking his last breath, and concludes with his face not being Kawasaki's, but having been transformed into the "ambiguous face of someone unknown."
In literary reviews of "Voices of the Fallen Heroes," at that time, while some expressed sympathy for parts of the work's content, there were few positive reviews expressing complete approval, due to the work's ideological aspects and criticism of the Emperor Shà Âwa. Because of the criticism of the Emperor, Mishima's home received numerous letters of protest and threats from established right-wingers. And, the established left-wing Japanese Communist Party condemned the work for being cast in "the rhetoric of the Right", in its official newspaper, Shimbun Akahata. On the other hand, Mishima's home received many "warm letters of gratitude, sympathy, and encouragement," and some even made the effort to visit him. Some even contacted him offering to provide bodyguards, saying, "If necessary, we may send several men to Tokyo to protect you from the Communists."
The reactions from the literary world were, Kiyoteru Hanada, while appreciating it to a certain extent as a critique of the Emperor from the right-wing, criticized it negatively, saying it "plays antics." Jun Età  criticized the work that it is a sensational and controversial work that astutely captures the voids in the national psyche, but what one senses from it is an "exposed idea," and he called it "ideological" and "strangely obscene" compared to "Patriotism," which, despite its theme of eroticism, was "surprisingly clean" and "aesthetic." Età  had a different understanding of Emperor Shà Âwa's "Declaration of Humanity" than Mishima, believing that the Emperor did not change just because he made that declaration. Shintaro Ishihara commented that it was a mistake for Mishima's methodology, which rejected the secular world, to embark on history.
and Takeo Okuno showed a certain understanding of the work and tried to understand Mishima's intentions. argued that the work is beautiful precisely because it is impossible to "reinstate" the spirits of the war dead. praised the work for its significance, as it seeks to console the souls of soldiers and restore their honor.
Kenkichi Yamamoto agreed with Mishima's motivation for creating the work, which was to criticize the "empty hypocrisy" and "disgusting vulgarity" brought about by postwar democracy, but commented that "for a Mishima's work, the imagination is impoverished." He also commented, as an aside, that while viewing the Emperor as a god was a "hard-nosed rational ideology that emerged after the Meiji era," he noted that compared to the "vulgarity of heart" of modern people who are unable to honestly cherish the "feelings and actions" of the officers in the February 26 Incident and Special Attack Units, the "mental space" of Meiji people who cherished the feelings and actions of the Aizu Byakkotai samurais who died for their feudal lord and the Tokugawa family was "far more admirable."
Jakucho Setouchi realized that the scene at the end of the story, in which the dead spiritual medium's face transforms into the "ambiguous face of someone unknown," is a metaphor to Emperor Shà Âwa, and thought that "Mishima-san has risked his life for this work," she immediately sent Mishima a letter. About its hidden intention, was replied, "I am extremely fortunate that the initial response to this work has been such generous praise." "The key is hidden in the last few lines, and it seems your keen insight has detected it. And you called this work Noh, I was aiming for a Shura mono. It is a small piece, but by writing this, I feel like I could at least make up some apology for having survived twenty years after the war." from Mishima.
Tsukasa Kono, the elder brother of Captain , the only officer who committed seppuku in the February 26 Incident, stated that Mishima's "Voices of the Fallen Heroes," clearly articulated things that "we as surviving families simply could not say" even more than 30 years after the incident. And he expressed gratitude that the work "pointedly articulated" both "an understanding of the young officers and, especially, distrust toward the Emperor," adding that "Mishima spoke for every single fervent wish that the incident's participants and their families wanted to express and sought to have understood."
And, in July, the month following the work was published, Tsukasa Kono visited Masaharu Gotà Âda, who was then the Vice-Commissioner of the National Police Agency, on a certain matter. Gotà Âda took "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" from his desk and asked, "Have you read this? What are your thoughts on it?" This was shown that the Metropolitan Police Department had promptly reviewed the work's content and was interested in it.
a historian and researcher of the , has begun by stating that his opinion was that "the theme of the Emperor and young officers in the February 26 Incident could only be fully portrayed by someone with the genius of Dostoevsky," and has given the reason for this as the theme holds "theological issues" and involves issues related to "the world of human faith, which has long been filled with fascination and fear, between orthodoxy and heresy." Hashikawa has evaluated "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" as being filled with "the rage and resentment of those banished from a certain supreme bliss" to an incredible degree, and that "the cries of those who stagger in pitiful forms on the border between the living and the dead come like a menacing low voice that reaches our ears as living beings." He went on to say that in the work, the author Mishima plays "the role of a shaman possessed by the souls of those who have turned into evil demons," and has explained as follows:
, a literary critic, has stated that "Voices of the Fallen Heroes," written in 1966, is one of Japan's most important works in the postwar period, saying that he is glad "that someone like Mishima existed in postwar Japan." He also has mentioned that "the meaning of postwar Japan" would have been "completely different" with or without Mishima, and that "without Mishima, Japan's postwar period would have ended up being a farce." Katà  has analyzed that Mishima's ideas expressed in "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" "have a universal line of thought that one would think if one were free from any preconceptions," and untainted by "local postwar logic in Japan," Mishima's presentation of "universal human thinking" for the first time made it clear "how paradoxical Japan's postwar linguistic space was." He then has offered the following commentary on the theme of this work, which includes the metaphor of the spirit medium Kawasaki's face changing into the "ambiguous face" of Emperor Shà Âwa at the end of the work:
Literary critic , looking at the historical background of the time, which was marked by the prosperity brought about by rapid economic growth and the resulting problems of pollution, both of which are also depicted in "Voices of the Fallen Heroes," has explained, "While the Japanese were becoming materially wealthy, they were also beginning to feel an incurable spiritual void in the context of their mass society," and has stated that Mishima threw this work at this "void."
In his essay on the kamikaze, Ivan Morris has observed that while the kamikaze pilots expressed a desire for repaying their obligation to their families, the Emperor, and the nation as one family, they did not simply believe in an afterlife or reincarnation. He has considered that they felt doubt, fear of death, and anguish, and they knowing Japan would defeat, yet they actively embraced their own demise through a unique Japanese spirit, and he has read the tradition of Bushido behind their preparedness. And Morris has touched upon Mishima's depiction in "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" where Mishima argues that it was not the defeat itself, but the Emperor's declaration of humanity that made it impossible to assuage the pilots' sense of failure and amounted to a posthumous profanation of their deaths, that because of the declaration turned the principle for which the fallen heroes sacrificed themselves into a "fictitious notion." But Morris has said, 'While having respect for Yukio Mishima, I believe that the motivations of the special attack corps volunteers were not as simple as the impression given by this elegy, but were considerably more complex."
Comparing "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" with the original Aoi no Ue, which Mishima used in his Modern Noh Play, The Lady Aoi, , a doctor of classical literature, has observed the parallel structure of "Rokujo no Miyasudokoro = Soldiers" and "Hikaru Genji = Emperor." Paying attention that Mishima wrote in his creative draft notes for "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" that "the medium dies. The incarnation of the Emperor," he has pointed out the similarities between "Kawasaki-kun," who died in cursing for long stretches by the heroic spirits of the February 26 Incident and the Kamikaze pilots, and Genji's wife "Aoi no Ue," who was cursed to death by Rokujà  no Miyasudokoro who was betrayed by Genji, but also deeply loved him. Shimauchi then has analyzed this as the true reason why the militia organization Mishima founded was named the "Tatenokai (Shield Society)," comes from classical waka included in the Man'yà Âshà «, was to protect from the cursing.
Shimauchi also has mentioned that in Mishima's play , the Marquis Suzaku accepts his own downfall and becomes a "shield," and that Mishima, who died after shouting three times, also tried to fulfill his role of "taking on the anger of the war dead" by becoming "my insignificant shield" for the "Emperor" (or the "imperial system") in the same way. Shimauchi also has speculated that because Mishima was able to understand the anger of the war dead, he "tried to take that anger upon himself," and just as Kawasaki-kun's dead face resembled "the face of the Emperor," Mishima's "dying for the Emperor" was the same as "dying as Emperor."
, a literary critic, has talked that "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" is a masterpiece that "boils down to terrific condensed" the themes of Saburo Shiroyama's 1959 novel At the End of the Great Cause and brings them together under the theme of a certain "grudge." He also has mentioned that in a dialogue with Tsuneari Fukuda, Mishima said, "The Japanese will never die to protect democracy," and has explained that what this work deals with is the issue of "faith" that goes beyond political systems like democracy, and that it describes Mishima's "grudge" toward the postwar period, which had robbed the Japanese people of their "faith," as well as his criticism of the Emperor's "Declaration of Humanity."
, a social engineer, has commented the composition of the depiction of the war dead gathering on the sea at night for a banquet and conversation as a striking visual image, calling it "extremely beautiful." And Kawabata has said, despite he being a relatively unreligious person, he could imagine "this is how Japan is sustained," and that the work's "beautiful composition is brimming with the Japanese view of the nation, ancestors, and life and death." He also has noted that the lines in the work, following the execution of the "Imperial Way Faction" officers who participated in the February 26 Incident, "the cause of our Imperial nation collapsed," and "the , Nazi-obsessed military clique paved the way for an unstoppable war," reflect Mishima's criticism of the "Control Faction" military and his view of modern Japanese history. And Kawabata himself has felt that from the February 26 Incident to the present day, the possibility of the "sincerity" of moving the society has been lost, and has argued that the work reminds us that since the incident, "the Japanese society has become nothing more than a mechanical system."
Mishima's mother, , recalled the moment Mishima handed her the manuscript of "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" as follows:
Shizue also said that two or three days before he began writing, Mishima had explained to her the impoverished and devastated conditions in rural TÃ Âhoku region at the time of the February 26 Incident, "with tears in his eyes."
Takeo Okuno said that when he read "Voices of the Fallen Heroes," he felt that Mishima might have been possessed by the spirit of Asaichi Isobe, and recalled that on July 29, 1959, when the Okuno couple, Tatsuhiko Shibusawa and his wife, and the painter and his wife were invited to Mishima's home and they were all playing Kokkuri-san, Mishima muttered in all seriousness, "The spirit of Isobe is interfering."
At a New Year's party held at Mishima's home on January 1, 1970, Mishima's disciple, actress heard Akihiro Maruyama say that the spirit of Asaichi Isobe was haunting Mishima, and at that moment, Mishima seemed shocked.
Director was approached by Mishima to see if he could stage "Voices of the Fallen Heroes" in the style of Noh. As DÃ Âmoto was planning the production, he considered performing the play in an outdoor theater in the style of bonfire Noh due to restrictions imposed by fire safety laws. He told Mishima about the idea of entrusting the specific direction to Tetsuji Takechi, but Takechi and Mishima had different political positions at the time, and Mishima hesitated to do so, and the idea did not come to fruition.
On 11 November of the same year that the work was published, Mishima was invited to attend the autumn with his wife. Takeo Okuno has said that "I was wondering that he was able to attend the party despite publishing such a work to curse the Emperor."
The diary of Sukemasa Irie, who served as a close aide to Emperor Shà Âwa for many years, contains an entry that indicates that Emperor Shà Âwa had some interest in Mishima and the . And, based on Emperor Shà Âwa's response to a question about the "Declaration of Humanity" at the Imperial Household Press Club in August 1977, Kenichi Matsumoto has speculated that Emperor Shà Âwa may have been aware of the passage in Mishima's "Voices of the Fallen Heroe" that reads, "Why has our Sumeragi become a human being?"