Shelter Island may refer to:
Places
- Shelter Island (Alaska), an island in the Alexander Archipelago, Alaska
- Shelter Island, Montana, an island in Flathead Lake, Montana
- Shelter Island (Hong Kong), an island in Port Shelter, Hong Kong
- Shelter Island (Western Australia), an island in Western Australia
- Shelter Island, New York, a town in Suffolk County, New York
- Shelter Island (CDP), New York, a hamlet and census-designated place in the above town
- Shelter Island Heights, New York, a hamlet and census-designated place in the above town
- Shelter Island Sound, a sound in Suffolk County, New York, surrounding Shelter Island
- Shelter Island (Fourth Lake), an island in Herkimer County, New York
- Shelter Island, San Diego, a neighbourhood of Point Loma in San Diego, California
- Shelter Island meteorite, Mars
Other