my-server
← Wiki Redirected from Scale property

Scale (descriptive set theory)

In the mathematical discipline of descriptive set theory, a scale is a certain kind of object defined on a set of points in some Polish space (for example, a scale might be defined on a set of real numbers). Scales were originally isolated as a concept in the theory of uniformization, but have found wide applicability in descriptive set theory, with applications such as establishing bounds on the possible lengths of wellorderings of a given complexity, and showing (under certain assumptions) that there are largest countable sets of certain complexities.

Formal definition

Given a pointset A contained in some product space

where each X<sub>k</sub> is either the Baire space or a countably infinite discrete set, we say that a norm on A is a map from A into the ordinal numbers. Each norm has an associated prewellordering, where one element of A precedes another element if the norm of the first is less than the norm of the second.

A scale on A is a countably infinite collection of norms

with the following properties:

If the sequence x<sub>i</sub> is such that
: x<sub>i</sub> is an element of A for each natural number i, and
: x<sub>i</sub> converges to an element x in the product space X, and
: for each natural number n there is an ordinal &lambda;<sub>n</sub> such that &phi;<sub>n</sub>(x<sub>i</sub>)=&lambda;<sub>n</sub> for all sufficiently large i, then
x is an element of A, and
for each n, &phi;<sub>n</sub>(x)&le;&lambda;<sub>n</sub>.

By itself, at least granted the axiom of choice, the existence of a scale on a pointset is trivial, as A can be wellordered and each &phi;<sub>n</sub> can simply enumerate A. To make the concept useful, a definability criterion must be imposed on the norms (individually and together). Here "definability" is understood in the usual sense of descriptive set theory; it need not be definability in an absolute sense, but rather indicates membership in some pointclass of sets of reals. The norms &phi;<sub>n</sub> themselves are not sets of reals, but the corresponding prewellorderings are (at least in essence).

The idea is that, for a given pointclass &Gamma;, we want the prewellorderings below a given point in A to be uniformly represented both as a set in &Gamma; and as one in the dual pointclass of &Gamma;, relative to the "larger" point being an element of A. Formally, we say that the &phi;<sub>n</sub> form a &Gamma;-scale on A if they form a scale on A and there are ternary relations S and T such that, if y is an element of A, then

where S is in &Gamma; and T is in the dual pointclass of &Gamma; (that is, the complement of T is in &Gamma;). Note here that we think of &phi;<sub>n</sub>(x) as being &infin; whenever x&notin;A; thus the condition &phi;<sub>n</sub>(x)&le;&phi;<sub>n</sub>(y), for y&isin;A, also implies x&isin;A.

The definition does not imply that the collection of norms is in the intersection of &Gamma; with the dual pointclass of &Gamma;. This is because the three-way equivalence is conditional on y being an element of A. For y not in A, it might be the case that one or both of S(n,x,y) or T(n,x,y) fail to hold, even if x is in A (and therefore automatically &phi;<sub>n</sub>(x)&le;&phi;<sub>n</sub>(y)=&infin;).

Applications

Scale property

The scale property is a strengthening of the prewellordering property. For pointclasses of a certain form, it implies that relations in the given pointclass have a uniformization that is also in the pointclass.

Periodicity

Notes

References