The Ottoman Empire had a number of tributary and vassal states throughout its history. Its tributary states would regularly send tribute to the Ottoman Empire, which was understood by both states as also being a token of submission. In exchange for certain privileges, its vassal states were obligated to render support to the Ottoman Empire when called upon to do so. Some of its vassal states were also tributary states.
These client states, many of which could be described by modern terms such as satellite states or puppet states, were usually on the periphery of the Ottoman Empire under suzerainty of the Sublime Porte, over which direct control was not established. The Ottoman Empire maintained relationships with various states, some of which were under their direct rule (provinces) and others that were vassal states or tributary states, meaning they recognized Ottoman suzerainty but retained a degree of autonomy.
Functions
Ottomans first demanded only a small yearly tribute from vassal princes, as a token of their submission. They later demanded that a vassal prince's son should be held as hostage, that the prince should come to the Palace once a year and swear allegiance, and that he should send auxiliary troops on the sultan's campaigns. Vassal princes were required to treat the sultan's friends and enemies as their own. If the vassal failed in these duties, his lands would be declared as darülharb (lit. territory of war) open to the raids of the Ghazis. The Ottomans considered as their vassals all states whose rulers agreed to pay tribute. Even the Habsburgs fell into this category after Ferdinand I (1526âÂÂ64) agreed to buy peace from the Ottomans in 1533. In fact, the Habsburgs were tributary (vassal?) in name only, as was Ragusa. Transylvania depended much more on the goodwill of the Ottomans than did those ruling in either Vienna or Ragusa, and the so-called Danubian Principalities, (Moldavia and Wallachia) were indeed vassal states in the strictest legal sense of the term. The territories the Ottomans had conquered were either administered as provinces or transformed into vassal states, such examples as Fezzan, which was an independent state conquered and turned into a vassal state. The Ottomans established a pattern of government within their own territories or principalities that were incorporated gradually through tribute and military alliance before there full annexation. The Ottomans would give local dynasty that would recognize themselves as vassals, particularly in border zones, this policy allowed local ruler to have local authority exchange for tribute such as military support and coinage, public rituals such as naming the sultan in khutba, while recognize the ottomans as head ruler, and serve as buffer zones.
Forms
- Some states within the eyalet system included sancakbeys who were local to their sanjak or who inherited their position (e.g., Samtskhe, some Kurdish sanjaks), areas that were permitted to elect their own leaders (e.g., areas of Albania, Epirus, and Morea (Mani Peninsula) was nominally a part of Aegean Islands Province but Maniot beys were tributary vassals of the Porte, or de facto independent eyalets (e.g., the Barbaresque 'regencies' Algiers, Tunisia, Tripolitania in the Maghreb, and later the Khedivate of Egypt). Egypt specifically had a unique case, Muhammad Ali Pasha became its Ottoman Governor but transformed himself to be its de facto ruler. He went to war with the Ottoman Sultan twice and established a dynasty that would rule Egypt until the revolution of 1952, even after the Ottoman sovereignty ended in 1914.
- Outside the eyalet system were states such as Moldavia, Wallachia and Transylvania which paid tribute to the Ottomans and over which the Porte had the right to nominate or depose the ruler, garrison rights, and foreign policy control. They were considered by the Ottomans as part of Dar al-'Ahd, thus they were allowed to preserve their self-rule, and were not under Islamic law, like the empire proper; Ottoman subjects, or Muslims for that matter, were not allowed to settle the land permanently or to build mosques.
- Territories Subject to the Caliphate. The Muslims of India (Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh), Sri Lanka, the Maldives, Afghanistan, Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia, Comoros, Kenya, Tanzania, Mozambique, the South of Africa, the western Turkestan Khanates (the Khanates of Khiva, Bukhara, and Kokand), and eastern Turkestan. Zanzibar sultanate
- Some states, such as Ragusa, paid tribute for the entirety of their territory and recognized Ottoman suzerainty.
- Others, such as the Sharif of Mecca, recognized Ottoman suzerainty but were subsidized by the Porte. The Ottomans were also expected to protect the Sharifate militarily â as suzerains over Mecca and Medina, the Ottoman sultans were meant to ensure the protection of the Hajj and Umrah pilgrimages and safe passage of pilgrims. The Amir al-hajj was a military officer appointed by the Sultanate to ensure this.
- During the nineteenth century, as Ottoman territory receded, several breakaway states from the Ottoman Empire had the status of vassal states (e.g. they paid tribute to the Ottoman Empire), before gaining complete independence. They were, however, de facto independent, including having their own foreign policy and their own independent military. This was the case with the principalities of Serbia, Romania and Bulgaria
- Some states paid tribute for possessions that were legally bound to the Ottoman Empire but not possessed by the Ottomans, such as the Habsburgs for parts of Royal Hungary or Venice for Zante.
There were also secondary vassals such as the Nogai Horde and the Circassians who were (at least nominally) vassals of the khans of Crimea, or some Berbers and Arabs who paid tribute to the North African beylerbeyis, who were in turn Ottoman vassals themselves. Other tribute from foreign powers included a kind of protection money, sometimes called a "horde tax" (similar to the Danegeld), paid by the Tsardom of Russia or the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. It was usually paid to the Ottoman vassal khans of Crimea rather than to the Ottoman sultan directly.
List of Ottoman tributaries and vassals
- Byzantine Empire (1371 â 20 February 1403, 1424 â 6 April 1453)
- Despotate of the Morea (1422âÂÂ1470)
- Empire of Trebizond (1456âÂÂ1461)
- Lordship of Prilep (1371âÂÂ1395)
- Dejanoviànoble family (1371âÂÂ1395)
- Principality of Wallachia (Eflâk PrensliÃÂi), 1396âÂÂ1397, 1417âÂÂ1861 with some interruptions.
- Principality of Moravian Serbia (1389âÂÂ1402)
- Despotate of Serbia (1402âÂÂ1459)
- Second Bulgarian Empire (14th century)
- Principality of Moldavia (BoÃÂdan PrensliÃÂi), 1456âÂÂ1457, 1503âÂÂ1861 with some interruptions.
- Republic of Ragusa (1458âÂÂ1808)(de facto 1458âÂÂ1699, de jure 1699âÂÂ1808)
- Republic of Venice (1475âÂÂ1603)
- (1533âÂÂ1540âÂÂ1606), tributary state
- Archduchy of Austria (1547âÂÂ1604, 1664)
- Kingdom of Bohemia, briefly in 1620 under Frederick I of Bohemia
- Duchy of Syrmia(1527âÂÂ1530)
- Crimean Khanate (Kñrñm HanlñÃÂñ), 1478âÂÂ1774
- Grand Principality of Moscow 1521 during the Crimean invasion of Russia
- Kazan Khanate (Kazan HanlñÃÂñ), 1523: Kazan briefly conquered by Crimean Khanate, Sahib I Giray enthroned as Khan
- PolishâÂÂLithuanian Commonwealth (16th century): paid a horde tax to the Crimean khans
- Budjak Horde (?âÂÂ1807)
- Circassian principalities and tribes
- Kabarda (?âÂÂ1739)
- Ochakov steppe or Yedisan (1684âÂÂ1760s)
- Jamboyluq Horde (also known as Perekop Horde)
- Astrakhan Khanate (1523 and 1549)
- Yedishkul Horde
- Lesser Nogai Horde
- Tsardom of Russia (1511âÂÂ1547âÂÂ1689)The Crimean khanate did several raids and Russia did agree to pay them tribute occasionally.Technically (but not de facto), Russia was a tributary of the Crimean khanate as the remaining successor of the Golden Horde, which was hard to defeat until about the 17th century
- Former Golden Horde Khanates
- Kazan Khanate (1521âÂÂ1531, 1533âÂÂ1546, 1546âÂÂ1551)Safa Giray ruled Kazan for 23 years as the Ottoman representative
- Kasim Khanate (1486âÂÂ1512)
- Lesser Nogai Khanate (1548âÂÂ1711)
- Bashkir Khanate (1656âÂÂ1738) came under Ottoman protection.
- Funjistan: Some sources suggest that Amara may have agreed to nominal tributary status or diplomatic recognition in exchange for autonomy. This allowed Sennar to remain effectively independent while giving the Ottomans a sense of regional control. (1517-1533/4)
- Tibesti, Wadai sultanate ,Tevarñks and Tîbûs.(18thâÂÂ1911) in the 1880s when French colonialism began to spread in the region of the lake chad, Tîbûs and Tevarñks sent representatives to the Ottoman StateâÂÂs Trablusgarp province and his leaders personally Demanded protection of the Ottomans against the enemy. They came under Ottoman protection but was hard to maintain due to its distance
- Emirate of Mount Lebanon (1516âÂÂ1842)
- Ma'n dynasty (1516âÂÂ1697)
- Chehab dynasty (1697âÂÂ1842)
- Arabian tribes under Ottoman rule
- Sharifate of Mecca (1517âÂÂ1803)
- Al Fadl, Mawali, Hassana, Ruwalla, Ageidet, Fedaan, and Sbaa (1516âÂÂ8th century)
- Hutaym (1553?âÂÂ19th century)
- Dulaim (?âÂÂ19th century)
- Mozabite tribe or Banu Mzab (1500sâÂÂ18th century)
- Latakia considered themselves vassals of the porte
- Turabay dynasty (1517âÂÂ1677)
- Emirate of Asir
- Emirate of Jabal Shammar (1836âÂÂ1921)
- Emirate of Najd (1818âÂÂ1918)
- Principality of Najran (1638âÂÂ1924 )
- Emirate of Dhala he was required by the Turkish authorities to make his submission to the Porte
- Zaydi Imams in the 19th century, Yemen was a nominal part of the Ottoman Empire, (see Islamic history of Yemen) (19thâÂÂ1922?)
- the emirates of Oman, Qatar, and Bahrain, obtaining their recognition of their allegiance to the Ottoman Empire. While Ottoman authority was nominally recognized in these regions, it was only nominally acknowledged.
- Regency of Algiers (1516âÂÂ1830)
- Kingdom of Tlemcen (1551âÂÂ1556)
- Sultanate of Tuggurt or tuoggourt (1552âÂÂ1830)
- Sultanate of Wargla (1552âÂÂ1830)
- Makhzen tribes
- Dhouaouda (1541âÂÂ1638) Dhouaouda signed the Pact of Barbarossa with the Ottomans and the emir of Biskra, Ali bin Sakhri pledged allegiance to the Ottoman Empire
- Ottoman Tripolitania
- Tuareg Confederations (semi-vassal relations) Tuareg tribes in the central Sahara (e.g., Kel Ajjer, Kel Ahaggar) paid tribute or acknowledged Ottoman Tripoli's authority intermittently.
- Sanjak of Benghazi (Bingazi SancaÃÂñ): autonomous sanjak. Formerly in the vilayet of Tripoli, but after 1875 dependent directly on the ministry of the interior at Constantinople
- Mamluk dynasty of Iraq (1704âÂÂ1831)
- Ottoman Tunisia (1574âÂÂ1881)
- Djerid (1570sâÂÂ1881)
- Muradid dynasty (1613âÂÂ1702)
- Husainid dynasty (1705âÂÂ1881)
- Awlad Muhammad (Fezzan) (1574âÂÂ1812)
- Riyyah tribe and Magarha
- Jabal al-Gharbi (1551?âÂÂ1812?)
- Sennusia (De facto vassal)
- Cyrenaica (Ottoman vassal until 1517âÂÂ1835, ottoman province until 1835âÂÂ1913)
- Anatolian beyliks under Ottoman rule
- Karamanids
- Candar dynasty (1402âÂÂ1440âÂÂ1461)
- Beylik of Ramazan (1517âÂÂ1608)
- Beylik of Sarukhan (1390âÂÂ1412)
- Beylik of Dulkadir (1515âÂÂ1522)
- Albanian tribes under Ottoman rule
- Pashalik of Yanina (1787âÂÂ1822)
- Pashalik of Berat (1774âÂÂ1809)
- Pashalik of Scutari (1757âÂÂ1831)
- League of Prizren (1878âÂÂ1881)
- Souliotes Confederacy (16th centuryâÂÂ1821)
- Mirdita (1416âÂÂ1912)
- Kelmendi 13th?âÂÂ1909?)
- Triesh or KuÃÂi (tribe)
- Mani Peninsula (1460âÂÂUntil 1878?)
- Little Cumania Came under special protection by Sultan Mehmet III
- Zagorisian (1431âÂÂ?)
- Tripolitania Karamanlis (1711âÂÂ1835)
- Zaporozhian Sich De jure vassal (1711âÂÂ1734)
- Danubian Sich (1775âÂÂ1828)
- Laghouat (14th? âÂÂ1727âÂÂ1828)
- Ouargla (1555âÂÂ1855)
- Shirvan (early 1724âÂÂ1725)
- After the Treaty of Constantinople (1578âÂÂ1606)
- Dagestan
- Khuzestan
- Luristan
- Shahrizor
- Shirvan
- Karabakh
- Erivan province
- Shamkhalate of Tarki (1580sâÂÂ1590s)
- Adal Sultanate Imam Ahmed agreed to formally recognize Ottoman suzerainty, pay 100,000 okkas of gold to the sultan, and send tribute worth another 2,000 okkas of gold annually to the Ottoman governor in Zebid, Mustafa al-Neshar. (1527âÂÂ1577)
- Eastern Africa/ Kilwa Swahilli (Mogadishu down to Mombasa and south-eastern African coast from the Zambezi to Mozambique)(1567âÂÂlate1580 to early 1600)
- Comoros Islands(briefly 1586-1590 part of the Swahili tribes)
- Lamoli (1584)
- Kilifi, Pate, Lamu and Faza recognize ottoman suzerainty
- Malindi briefly seized the city (1595âÂÂ1598)
- Barawa (1585âÂÂ1590) becomes Ottoman vassal
- Zanzibar (16th century) (the island, briefly under Ottoman protection before the Portuguese regained control)
- Duchy of the Archipelago (1537, 1565âÂÂ1579)
- Eastern Hungarian Kingdom (1526âÂÂ1551, 1556âÂÂ1570)
- Samtskhe-Saatabago (atabegate) (1500âÂÂ1625)
- Kingdom of Imereti (1555âÂÂ1804)
- Principality of Svaneti (1555âÂÂ1804)
- Principality of Mingrelia (1557âÂÂ1803)
- Principality of Mingrelia (1568âÂÂ1803)
- Principality of Guria (1614âÂÂ1810)
- Principality of Abkhazia (1555âÂÂ1810)
- Kingdom of Kartli (1578âÂÂ1612, 1723âÂÂ1736)
- (1578âÂÂ1612, 1723 âÂÂ1736)
- KanemâÂÂBornu Empire (1580âÂÂ1603) Borno was dependent nominally to the Ottoman Empire, as they were taken as an obedient vassal.
- Hilaalee dynasty of The Maldives (1565?âÂÂ1737?âÂÂ1900?) the Maldivian monarchs during the 15thâÂÂ18thâÂÂ20th functioned as a vassal state under the suzerainty of the Ottoman Empire.
- Principality of Transylvania (Erdel), 1570âÂÂ1699 with some interruptions
- Székely Land (1570?âÂÂ1870)
- Partium (1541âÂÂ5 September 1619)
- PolishâÂÂLithuanian Commonwealth (1577âÂÂ1586): briefly considered a vassal/tributary state under the Ottoman. The Ottoman Empire, by placing the Kingdom of Poland under its protection in July 30 1577, from the Habsburgs actions. extended its influence/Suzerain into the lands of Belarus, northern Ukraine, Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia, reaching as far as the Baltic Sea. After Henryk II Walezy of the French House of Valois fled to France to be crowned, Sokollu Mehmed Pasha intervened in the succession disputes in Poland and had Stephen Báthory, the voivode of Transylvania, which at the time was subject to the Ottoman Empire, elected as "King of Poland." This making Poland subjected to Murad III. Bathory now based his domestic and foreign policy on Ottomans. Ottoman influence weakened, and during the rule of Sigismund III Vasa, who came to the throne in 1586, it disappeared completely. But in September 16, 1591 The treaty of September, in the presence of Turgut ÃÂavuÃ
Â. agreed to pay the ottomans a tribute of 250.000. This lifted Ottoman influence over Poland. Ottoman influence persisted for many years Poland paid an annual tribute to the Ottomans after Treaty of Buchach (1672âÂÂ1676)
- Duchy of Prussia (1576âÂÂ1586)
- Duchy of Livonia (1576âÂÂ1586)
- Duchy of Courland and Semigallia (1576âÂÂ1586, 1672âÂÂ1676)
- Sultanate of Aceh, 1569âÂÂ1903
- Johor (1556âÂÂ1582âÂÂ1623)
- Pahang (1617âÂÂ1623?)
- Kedah (1619âÂÂ1630?)
- Perak (1620âÂÂ1629?)
- Deli (1612âÂÂ1636?)
- Aru (1565âÂÂ1636?)
- Nias (1624âÂÂ1636?)
- Siak (1615âÂÂ1636?)
- Indragiri (1615âÂÂ1636?)
- Jambi (1615âÂÂ1636?)
- Saadi sultanate(1576âÂÂ1582 vassal 1582âÂÂ1587 protection)
- Wattasid dynasty (1549âÂÂ1549âÂÂ1554)
- Emirate of Harar (1782?âÂÂ1875?, 1875âÂÂ1887) was a subject state of the Khedivate of Egypt/Ottoman Empire
- Five independent Assyrian tribes of Hakkâri (Tyari, Baz, Jilu, Tkhuma and Diz)
- Kurdish emirates (16thâÂÂ19th centuries) peacefully vassalized after the Ottoman-Iraqi War, when Kurds were allowed their own state. Most Kurdish Emirates was in bad condition an agreed to become an Ottoman tributary.
- Principality of Zirqan (1512âÂÂ1835)
- Principality of Suleyman (1514âÂÂ1839)
- Mukriyan (1583âÂÂ1609?)
- Ardalind dynasty (1578âÂÂ1603, 1623âÂÂ1639, 1723âÂÂ1736?)
- Mukriyan (under the Ardalind)
- Baban (16thâÂÂ1850)
- Bohtan (1514âÂÂ1855)
- Principality of EÃÂil (?âÂÂ1864)
- Emirate of Hakkâri (?âÂÂ1847) The allegiance of the Hakkâri rulers fluctuated between different overlords ( ottoman and safavid ) in subsequent years
- Emirate of Kilis (1515âÂÂ1610)
- Principality of Mahmudi (1548âÂÂ1604)
- Emirate of Biradost (1510? Or 1534? âÂÂ1603)
- Emirate of Palu (1517âÂÂ1839)
- Emirate of Pazooka (1517-1587)
- Principality of Montenegro (KaradaàPrensliÃÂi), (1516âÂÂ1696âÂÂ1878)
- Cossack Hetmanate: Protectorate and Sanjak of the Ottoman Empire (1655âÂÂ1663) and (June 1669 â 1685) The Ottomans continued to recognize some use for the Cossack vassal state and appointed lurii as Hatmanate.
- Principality of Upper Hungary (modern-day Slovakia), 1682âÂÂ1685 under Imre Thököly
- Danubian Sich
- Sultanate of Darfur (1915âÂÂ1916)
- Derebeys Feudal Lords (18thâÂÂ19th century)
- Septinsular Republic (1800âÂÂ1807)
- Mauritius Island they considered themselves Ottoman subjects (19thâÂÂ20th?)
- Principality of Serbia (Sñrbistan PrensliÃÂi) (1815âÂÂ1878 de facto independence, 1867 de jure independence 1878) <nowiki/>[<nowiki/>Russian empire]
- Al-Muntafiq (1530âÂÂ1918)
- United Principalities of Romania (Romanya PrensliÃÂi) 1862âÂÂ1877
- Yettishar (1865âÂÂ1877)
- Khanate of Kokand
- Khedivate of Egypt (Mñsñr) 1867âÂÂ1914 de jure under Ottoman suzerainty, in effect fully autonomous, and from 1882 under British occupation; broke away from Ottoman suzerainty upon Ottoman entry into World War I on the side of the Central Powers and reformed as the "Sultanate of Egypt" which was declared a British protectorate on 5 November 1914, the day when Britain and France declared war against the Ottoman Empire. Britain also formally annexed Cyprus (under British administration since the Cyprus Convention in 1878, but nominally still an Ottoman territory) until 5 November 1914.
- Ja'alin tribe (1820âÂÂ1822)
- Uganda (modern day Equatoria) (1872âÂÂ1882)
- Principality of Bulgaria (Bulgaristan PrensliÃÂi) (1878âÂÂ1908) de facto independent.
- Principality of Samos (Sisam) 1835âÂÂ1912: established as an autonomous tributary principality under a Christian Prince; annexed to Greece during the First Balkan War
- Eastern Rumelia (DoÃÂu Rumeli) (1878âÂÂ1885) established by the Treaty of Berlin on 13 July 1878 as an autonomous province, in a personal union with the tributary Principality of Bulgaria on 6 September 1885 but remained de jure under Ottoman suzerainty; annexed by Bulgaria on 5 October 1908.
- Cyprus (Kñbrñs) (1878âÂÂ1914) established British administration under Ottoman suzerainty with the Cyprus Convention of 4 June 1878; annexed by Britain on 5 November 1914, upon Ottoman entry into World War I.
- Qatar (Katar) (1872âÂÂ1913)
- Cretan State (Girit) (1898âÂÂ1912/13) established as an internationally supervised tributary state headed by a Christian governor; in 1908 the Cretan parliament unilaterally declared union with Greece; the island was occupied by Greece in 1912, and de jure annexed in 1913
See also
References
Further reading
- Gábor Kármán (ed.), Tributaries and Peripheries of the Ottoman Empire, BRILL, 2020.
- Ahmad Al-Sharif, The Sahara: A Political and Economic History (1979)
- J. Despois, Les Touaregs du Hoggar (1957) (18thâÂÂ19th centuries)
- Books on the Ottoman Expansion Area
Ahmet Akgündüz, Unknown Ottoman, Istanbul 1999
Ahmet Kavas, From Past to Present Africa, Istanbul 2005
Ahmet Kavas, OttomanâÂÂAfrica Relations, TASAM Publications, Istanbul 2006
Hatice UÃÂur, A Sultanate in Ottoman Africa: Zanzibar, Istanbul: Küre Publications, 2005 [Link]
Türkiye Newspaper, Encyclopedia of the Ottoman Empire
1970 Hayat Encyclopedia
Erhan Afyoncu, The Ottoman Empire with Questions
ðlber Ortaylñ, The Ottomans
- From the works of Ahmet Kavas:
- âÂÂThe Dominance and Influence of the Ottoman Empire on the African ContinentâÂÂ, Yeni Türkiye Journal Ottoman Special Issue, I, 421-430 (2000). English translation of the same article. âÂÂThe Dominance and Influence of the Ottoman Empire on the African ContinentâÂÂ, The Great Ottoman, Turkish Civilisation, Ankara 2000, I, p. 248-258
- âÂÂThe Relations of the Ottoman Empire with the Muslim Emirate of Harar and Its Effect on the Rapprochement with the Christian Abyssinian (Ethiopian) EmpireâÂÂ, Pax Ottomana Studies in Memoriam Prof. Dr. Nejat GÃÂYÃÂNÃÂ, Sota-Yeni Türkiye Publications, Haarlem-Ankara 2001, p. 443-464
- âÂÂThe Establishment of the Gat District in the Great Sahara and OttomanâÂÂTuareg RelationsâÂÂ, Journal of Islamic Studies, 3, 171-196 (1999)
- âÂÂOttomanâÂÂTibu Relations: The Establishment of the ReÃ
Ââde (Chad) and Kavar (Niger) Districts in the Great SaharaâÂÂ, Journal of Islamic Studies, 4, 69-104 (2000)
- âÂÂThe Islamic Policy Implemented by France in North and West Africa: The Issue of Rejecting the Call for Jihad Published by Sultan ReÃ
ÂadâÂÂ, Religious Studies, 6, 23-50 (April 2000)
- âÂÂThe Last Bilad al-Sudan State Founded by Rabih b. Fazlullah Before the Colonisation of Africa and His Struggle with FranceâÂÂ, Ottoman Studies, XX, 9-35 (2000)
- âÂÂOttoman Sovereignty on the East African Coast: The Position of the Zeila Port in Northern Somalia (1265-1334/1849-1916)âÂÂ, Journal of Islamic Studies, issue: 5, 2001, p. 109-134
- âÂÂA Poor Field in Turkish Academic Research: Ottoman AfricaâÂÂ, Journal of Turkish Studies Literature (Talid), Vol: 1, No: 2, 2003, Foundation for Science and Art Turkish Studies Center, Istanbul, p. 513-528
- âÂÂThe Relations of the Ottoman Empire with the Indigenous People in North AfricaâÂÂ, International Congress on Science and Education in the Ottoman World, Istanbul, 12âÂÂ15 April 1999