The NESCAC tournament began in 2000 after the nine NESCAC left ECAC East to form the ice hockey division for their primary conference. The tournament has been held annually ever since with the winner receiving a bid to the Division III National Tournament. The 2021 tournament was cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
<small>Note: Middlebury served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Middlebury served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Middlebury served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Middlebury served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Middlebury served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Trinity served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Middlebury served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Bowdoin served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Colby served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Amherst served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Bowdoin served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Williams served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Amherst served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Bowdoin served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Trinity served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Amherst served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Trinity served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Hamilton served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Trinity served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Trinity served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Williams served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Colby served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Amherst served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Trinity served as host for the Semifinal and Championship rounds.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>
<small>Note: Semifinal and championship rounds held at the Russell Sage Rink.</small>
<small>Note: * denotes overtime period(s)</small>