In recent years, many megaliths have been discovered in the Urals: dolmens, menhirs and a large megalithic cultic complex on Vera Island.
Dolmens of the Middle Urals
At present, more than 200 dolmens have been discovered in the Sverdlovsk Oblast. Specificity of the dolmens in the Middle Urals is their relatively small size (width and length no more than 1.5 - 2.5 m) and original constructions. Based on differences in their construction, it is possible to distinguish two main types of dolmen:
1. dolmens of stone plates and mound;
2. boulder dolmens.
Dolmens of stone plates are structures consisting of a mound of stones and soil, with a stone chamber attached to it. Usually there is a square court in front of such dolmens. Sometimes such a court is surrounded by stones. The boulder dolmens had been made of massive boulders forming a chamber. From above the chamber is covered by either one or several flat boulders. Despite the differences of form and size of their chambers, all the boulder dolmens are identical in one respect: they all have two entrances - the main entrance (in one of its side walls) and another, narrower entrance between the boulders.
Menhirs
The most common megalithic structures of the steppe area of the Urals are menhirs. They are crude or roughly finished stones standing on the surface. This type of object is also found in forested areas, but very rarely and usually associated with dolmens. There are several types of menhirs in the Southern Urals: single, stone rows, complexes of menhirs, and circular structures of menhirs.
All discovered single menhirs are usually situated close to Bronze Age settlements or cemeteries. For this reason, archaeologists believe that they date from this period, and the evidence of limited excavations does not contradict this conclusion. Stone rows are for the most part oriented in an eastâÂÂwest direction. The length of some known rows is 13âÂÂ18 m. The most massive stones are situated in the center, forming the core of the composition. Topography of the stone rows (their location in landscape) is very variable and has no clear strong pattern.
An unexpected discovery is a circular structure of menhirs at the village of Akhunovo in Bashkiria. This is a circular structure with a diameter of about 25 m, and consisting of eight menhirs. The two largest stones are aligned in the northâÂÂsouth direction inside the ring. One of these central stones is surrounded by a ring (diameter 3.5 m) of post holes. The position these holes precisely repeats the structure of the whole stone ring, each hole corresponds to a menhir of the ring.
Vera Island
The greatest megalithic complex of the Ural Mountains is situated on Vera Island in Lake Turgoyak. It belongs to the Chalcolithic (Eneolithic) period. There are several objects:
Megalith âÂÂ1
The biggest structure of the island is megalith No.1 â a stone drywall construction 19ÃÂ6 m, cut into the bedrock and covered with megalithic capstones. The megalith is oriented westâÂÂeast. An entrance, partly destroyed now, is in the east. Inside the megalith consists of the long entrance, a Central hall and two chambers (Western and Northern), connected by a corridor one another. The height of all the chambers (with the exception of the low corridors) is no less than 1.9 m, often more than 2 m. The presence of windows and stone sculptures of heads of animals (bull and wolf), together with impressive size of the megalith, distinguish it from other megalithic buildings of the island. It seems that megalith 1 was a temple built for rituals connected with any transitions from one condition to another: rituals of either age initiations or change of status (lodgment of power of a chief or priest).
Megalith âÂÂ2
Megalith No.2 is a cut in a rocky slope and covered by a mound stone structure oriented northâÂÂsouth, whose internal size is 7.5 m à1.7 m à3.5 m. It consists of two chambers connected by a corridor. The entrance of the southern chamber is faced to the west. It has a double portal, it could serve for penetrating sun rays.
Megalith âÂÂ3
One more megalithic structure (No. 3) consists of large boulders (weight of the largest of them is at least 14-15 ton). Between the boulders a square pit is situated cut in rock. Vertical stone slabs were closing both sides of the construction. Massive boulders had been prepared as capstones. In the east the complex has a mound made of broken stone, but it has been not excavated yet.
Vera Island 9
There is a cultic ritual place on the island (Vera Island 9) consisted of two menhirs whose axis line sets a direction westâÂÂeast. This direction is very typical of megalithic orientations of the island. In addition to this there were two fireplaces and a large altar stone. There is one larger menhir in the south-east. This menhir had been erected to mark a direction to the sunset in midwinter. The destination of this open-air sanctuary was rituals connected with seasonal circles.
Vera Island 4
A cultic place (5.5ÃÂ4 m) surrounded by vertical stones and paved with massive granite plates tightly adjusted to one another is situated on the settlements of Vera Island 4. There was a small menhir in a center of this place. The exact destination is unknown.
A quarry is a unique addition to the megalithic complex of the island. Stones of the quarry have clear traces of copper tools as well as wooden wedges. By means of these wedges and water ancient megalithic builders could cut granite and extract needed stone blocks. There are also traces of extractions of large stone plates used as megalithic capstones.
Geoglyph
The discovery of a giant land art drawing of a moose or elk was made by Alexander Shestakov using satellite imagery and reported on in 2011 in the journal Antiquity. The geoglyph is located on the slopes of the Zyuratkul Mountains and has accurate contours of an animal similar to elk (54ÃÂ56'33" N 59ÃÂ11'32" E). Precisely under the contour on depth of to the stone laying wide was unearthed. Its borders consisted of large stones, and the center was filled with small stones. Builders of the object cut off a soil layer up to virgin clay, and placed stones into this trench. Now the stones are covered by a layer of patina and have a dark shade. But earlier they were light and were perfectly visible from the ridge, because the size of the drawing is huge. Its width is of , the length of , and the diagonal of . It is unknown today, whether this geoglyph belongs to the period of the same megalithic culture, as megaliths of the Vera Island. Everywhere, from geoglyphs in the Nazca Lines to the Blythe geoglyphs in California and several in England it is very difficult to date them. But a very early date for this geoglyph is probable. In the period of its creation the soil layer was only , and today it is to .
In 2012, Stanislav Grigoriev from the Russian Academy of Sciences Institute of History and Archaeology has suggested that stone tools found during recent excavations show a style of Lithic reduction dating to the Neolithic or Eneolithic periods between 4000 and 2000 BCE. This suggested dating would place the construction of the geoglyph many centuries before that of the Nazca lines in Peru, build around 500 CE.
See also
References
Literature:
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ. ÃÂõýÃÂÃÂõýøý ÃÂ.ÃÂ. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøõ ÃÂþþÃÂÃÂöõýøàþÃÂÃÂÃÂþòð ÃÂõÃÂð ýð þ÷õÃÂõ âÃÂÃÂóþÃÂú ò îöýþü ÃÂðÃÂÃÂðûÃÂõ // ÃÂ÷òõÃÂÃÂøàçõûÃÂñøýÃÂúþóþ ýðÃÂÃÂýþóþ ÃÂõýÃÂÃÂð, 2004. ÃÂÃÂÿ. 1, ÃÂ. 208âÂÂ213. http://www.csc.ac.ru/news/2004_1/2004_1_13_2.zip
- ÃÂðÃÂøýð î.ÃÂ., ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøõ ÃÂþþÃÂÃÂöõýøàýð þ÷õÃÂõ âÃÂÃÂóþÃÂú ò îöýþü ÃÂðÃÂÃÂðûÃÂõ // ÃÂÃÂýøÃÂõÃÂúøõ ò÷ðøüþôõùÃÂÃÂòøàýð îöýþü ãÃÂðûõ. çõûÃÂñøýÃÂú: àøÃÂõù, 2004. á. 30âÂÂ33.
- ÃÂþôÃÂÃÂÃÂ
ÃÂ.ÃÂ. ÃÂþø òÃÂÃÂÃÂõÃÂø àðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúøüø ÿðüÃÂÃÂýøúðüø // çõÃÂòõÃÂÃÂÃÂõ ÃÂõÃÂÃÂþòÃÂúøõ ÃÂÃÂõýøÃÂ. ÃÂúðÃÂõÃÂøýñÃÂÃÂó: ÃÂúòð-ÃÂÃÂõÃÂÃÂ, 2004, ÃÂ. 225âÂÂ228.
- ÃÂõÿþüýÃÂÃÂøù ÃÂ.ÃÂ. "ãÃÂðûÃÂÃÂúøõ ôþûÃÂüõýÃÂ": ò÷óûÃÂô úÃÂðõòõôþò // çõÃÂòõÃÂÃÂÃÂõ ÃÂõÃÂÃÂþòÃÂúøõ ÃÂÃÂõýøÃÂ. ÃÂúðÃÂõÃÂøýñÃÂÃÂó: ÃÂúòð-ÃÂÃÂõÃÂÃÂ, 2004, ÃÂ. 229âÂÂ230.
- ÃÂþÃÂþ÷þò ÃÂ.ÃÂ., áòÃÂÃÂþò ÃÂ.ÃÂ., çðøÃÂúøý á.ÃÂ. ÃÂþòÃÂù ÃÂøÿ ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúøÃÂ
ÿðüÃÂÃÂýøúþò óþÃÂýþ-ûõÃÂýþóþ ÃÂðÃÂÃÂðûÃÂà// çõÃÂòõÃÂÃÂÃÂõ ÃÂõÃÂÃÂþòÃÂúøõ ÃÂÃÂõýøÃÂ. ÃÂúðÃÂõÃÂøýñÃÂÃÂó: ÃÂúòð-ÃÂÃÂõÃÂÃÂ, 2004, ÃÂ. 231âÂÂ236.
- Grigoriev S.A., Vasina J.V., 2005. The megalithic constructions of the Vera Island on the Turgoyak Lake in the Southern Transurals // Comparative archaeology. https://web.archive.org/web/20110416045639/http://www.comp-archaeology.org/GrigMegtUrals.htm
- ÃÂðÃÂøýð î.ÃÂ., ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ. àõúþóýþÃÂÃÂøÃÂþòþÃÂýÃÂõ øÃÂÃÂûõôþòðýøàüõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøÃÂ
ÃÂþþÃÂÃÂöõýøù ýð þ÷õÃÂõ âÃÂÃÂóþÃÂú ò îöýþü ÃÂðÃÂÃÂðûÃÂõ // ÃÂ÷òõÃÂÃÂøàçõûÃÂñøýÃÂúþóþ ýðÃÂÃÂýþóþ ÃÂõýÃÂÃÂð. 2005, òÃÂÿ. 2, ÃÂ. 105âÂÂ109. http://www.csc.ac.ru/news/2005_2/2005_2_13_2.zip
- ÃÂõÿþüýÃÂÃÂøù ÃÂ.ÃÂ. àøÃÂõùÃÂúøõ ôþûÃÂüõýÃÂ. ÃÂúðÃÂõÃÂøýñÃÂÃÂó: äøûðýÃÂÃÂþÿ, 2005 - 28 ÃÂ.
- ÃÂðòÃÂøûÃÂú ÃÂ.ÃÂ., ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂðÃÂúþò á.á., 2006. ÃÂþóÃÂõñðûÃÂýÃÂõ ÿðüÃÂÃÂýøúø ÃÂÿþÃÂ
ø ñÃÂþý÷à// ÃÂÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøàîöýþóþ ãÃÂðûð áÃÂõÿÃÂ. çõûÃÂñøýÃÂú: àøÃÂõù. á. 89âÂÂ152.
- Grigoriev S.A. The Ural Megaliths and the European tradition: Chronological and Cultural Contexts // XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences. Book of Abstracts. V. I. Lisbon, 2006. P. 426.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂòðÃÂÃÂúþ ÃÂ.ÃÂ., áûõÿÃÂÃÂ
øý á.ÃÂ., ÃÂõÃÂôÃÂóøýð ÃÂ.î., ÃÂðûøý á.á.. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúðàÃÂÃÂðôøÃÂøàýð ãÃÂðûõ ø ÿÃÂþñûõüð ÿÃÂÃÂüøýÃÂúøÃÂ
ôþûÃÂüõýþò // ÃÂ÷òõÃÂÃÂøàçõûÃÂñøýÃÂúþóþ ýðÃÂÃÂýþóþ ÃÂõýÃÂÃÂð, 2006, òÃÂÿ. 3. á. 114âÂÂ118. http://www.csc.ac.ru/ej/file/3354
- ÃÂðÃÂøýð î.ÃÂ., ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂàþÃÂÃÂÃÂþòð ÃÂõÃÂà- ðÃÂÃÂ
õþðÃÂÃÂÃÂþýþüøÃÂõÃÂúøù ðÃÂÿõúà// ÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂþýþüøÃÂõÃÂúþõ ø üøÃÂþòþ÷÷ÃÂõýÃÂõÃÂúþõ ÃÂþôõÃÂöðýøõ ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúøÃÂ
ÿðüÃÂÃÂýøúþò îöýþóþ ãÃÂðûð. âõ÷øÃÂàôþúûðôþò ÿþûõòþóþ ÃÂõüøýðÃÂð. çõûÃÂñøýÃÂú: çõûÃÂã, 2006. á. 25âÂÂ27.
- ÃÂõÃÂÃÂþò ä.ÃÂ., 2006. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøù úþüÿûõúàÃÂÃÂ
ÃÂýþòþ: ôÃÂõòýÃÂàÿÃÂøóþÃÂø÷þýÃÂýðàþñÃÂõÃÂòðÃÂþÃÂøà// ÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂþýþüøÃÂõÃÂúþõ ø üøÃÂþòþ÷÷ÃÂõýÃÂõÃÂúþõ ÃÂþôõÃÂöðýøõ ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúøÃÂ
ÿðüÃÂÃÂýøúþò îöýþóþ ãÃÂðûð. çõûÃÂñøýÃÂú: çõûÃÂã, ÃÂ. 27âÂÂ31.
- ÃÂþûÃÂúþòð ÃÂ.ÃÂ., 2006. ÃÂÃÂÃÂþÃÂøàø÷ÃÂÃÂõýøàüõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøÃÂ
ÿðüÃÂÃÂýøúþò îöýþóþ ÃÂðÃÂÃÂðûÃÂà// ÃÂÃÂýøÃÂõÃÂúøõ ò÷ðøüþôõùÃÂÃÂòøàýð îöýþü ãÃÂðûõ. çõûÃÂñøýÃÂú: çõûÃÂã, ÃÂ. 61âÂÂ65.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂðÃÂøýð î.ÃÂ., ÃÂþÃÂþò ÃÂ.ÃÂ., ÃÂòðÃÂÃÂúþ ÃÂ.ÃÂ. ÃÂÃÂþñûõüð ôðÃÂøÃÂþòúø üõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøÃÂ
úþüÿûõúÃÂþò ãÃÂðûð // XVII ãÃÂðûÃÂÃÂúþõ ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúþõ ÃÂþòõÃÂðýøõ. ÃÂðÃÂõÃÂøðûàýðÃÂÃÂýþù úþýÃÂõÃÂõýÃÂøø (ÃÂúðÃÂõÃÂøýñÃÂÃÂó, 19-22 ýþÃÂñÃÂà2007 ó.). - ÃÂúðÃÂõÃÂøýñÃÂÃÂó - áÃÂÃÂóÃÂÃÂ: ø÷ô-òþ "ÃÂðóõûûðý", 2007, ÃÂ. 82, 83.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂòðÃÂÃÂúþ ÃÂ.ÃÂ., ÃÂþÃÂþò ÃÂ.ÃÂ. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøõ úþüÿûõúÃÂàãÃÂðûð, ÿÃÂþñûõüð øÃÂ
ôðÃÂøÃÂþòúø ø ÿÃÂþøÃÂÃÂ
þöôõýøà(ÿþ üðÃÂõÃÂøðûðü ÃÂðÃÂúþÿþú ýð þ÷õÃÂõ âÃÂÃÂóþÃÂú ò 2007 ó.) // ÃÂÃÂüðýøÃÂðÃÂýÃÂõ ýðÃÂúø ò ÃÂðÃÂúþÃÂÃÂþÃÂÃÂðýõ: ÃÂÃÂÃÂþÃÂøàø ÃÂþòÃÂõüõýýþÃÂÃÂÃÂ: ÃÂðÃÂõÃÂøðûàÃÂõöôÃÂýðÃÂþôýþù ýðÃÂÃÂýþ-ÿÃÂðúÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúþù úþýÃÂõÃÂõýÃÂøø, ÿþÃÂòÃÂÃÂõýýþù 75-ûõÃÂøàÃÂýÃÂÃÂøÃÂÃÂÃÂð øÃÂÃÂþÃÂøø, ÃÂ÷ÃÂúð ø ûøÃÂõÃÂðÃÂÃÂÃÂàãÃÂøüÃÂúþóþ ýðÃÂÃÂýþóþ ÃÂõýÃÂÃÂð àÃÂÃÂ. - ãÃÂð: ÃÂøûõü, 2007, ÃÂ. 78âÂÂ80.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂðÃÂøýð î.ÃÂ. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂàîöýþóþ ãÃÂðûð ø ÿÃÂþñûõüð øÃÂ
ÃÂ
ÃÂþýþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúþù ø úÃÂûÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂýþù øýÃÂõÃÂÿÃÂõÃÂðÃÂøø // ÃÂðÃÂþôàáðÃÂðÃÂþòÃÂúþóþ ÃÂþòþûöÃÂÃÂ: ÃÂÃÂýþûþóøÃÂ, ÃÂÃÂýþóÃÂðÃÂøÃÂ, ôÃÂÃÂ
þòýðàø üðÃÂõÃÂøðûÃÂýðàúÃÂûÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂð. áðÃÂðÃÂþò: "âÃÂøÃÂüÃÂ", 2006. á. 115âÂÂ125.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂðÃÂøýð î.ÃÂ., ÃÂòðÃÂÃÂúþ ÃÂ.ÃÂ., ÃÂþÃÂþò ÃÂ.ÃÂ. áþ÷ôðýøõ üÃÂ÷õàüõóðûøÃÂþò ýð þÃÂÃÂÃÂþòõ ÃÂõÃÂà// ÃÂþÃÂÃÂþÃÂýøõ ÿþúþûõýøù. 1 (4) 2008, ÃÂ. 18âÂÂ23.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂðÃÂøýð î.ÃÂ. ÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂþò ÃÂõÃÂà= Grigoriev, S.A., Vasina, Yu.V. Vera Island // îöýÃÂù ãÃÂðû. ÃÂÃÂÃÂõÃÂõÃÂÃÂòøõ ÃÂõÃÂõ÷ ÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂõûõÃÂøà= South Ural. Traveling through millenniums. Chelyabinsk: Krokus, 2009. P. 11âÂÂ15.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ. ÃÂõüûõÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂõýøàò óþûþÃÂõýõ ýð ãÃÂðûõ ø øÃÂ
ÃÂòÃÂ÷ààúûøüðÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøüø ø÷üõýõýøÃÂüø // ÃÂõþóÃÂðÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúþõ ÿÃÂþÃÂÃÂÃÂðýÃÂÃÂòþ: ÃÂñðûðýÃÂøÃÂþòðýýþõ ÃÂð÷òøÃÂøõ ÿÃÂøÃÂþôàø þñÃÂõÃÂÃÂòð. - çõûÃÂñøýÃÂú: ÃÂÃÂàÃÂá, 2009. - á. 15âÂÂ25.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂðÃÂøýð î.ÃÂ., ÃÂòðÃÂÃÂúþ ÃÂ.ÃÂ., ÃÂþÃÂþò ÃÂ.ÃÂ. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúøõ úþüÿûõúÃÂàãÃÂðûð: ÿÃÂþñûõüð ôðÃÂøÃÂþòúø // âÃÂÃÂôàII (XVIII) ÃÂÃÂõÃÂþÃÂÃÂøùÃÂúþóþ ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúþóþ ÃÂÃÂõ÷ôð ò áÃÂ÷ôðûõ. â I - ÃÂ,: ÃÂààÃÂÃÂ, 2008, ÃÂ. 204âÂÂ206.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ., ÃÂòðÃÂÃÂúþ ÃÂ.ÃÂ. ÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂþò ÃÂõÃÂÃÂ. ÃÂÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúøù üÃÂ÷õù-÷ðÿþòõôýøú ÿþô þÃÂúÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂü ýõñþü // áñþÃÂýøú ýðÃÂÃÂýÃÂÃÂ
ÃÂÃÂðÃÂõù ø üðÃÂõÃÂøðûþò ÃÂÃÂðÃÂÃÂýøúþò V ÃÂõöôÃÂýðÃÂþôýþù ýðÃÂÃÂýþ-ÿÃÂðúÃÂøÃÂõÃÂúþù úþýÃÂõÃÂõýÃÂøø. ÃÂÃÂþñûõüàÃÂÃÂÃÂþùÃÂøòþóþ ÃÂð÷òøÃÂøàóþÃÂþôþò. - ÃÂøðÃÂÃÂ: ÃÂÃÂàÃÂóõýÃÂÃÂÃÂòþ "âÃÂààÃÂ"; ÃÂõþÃÂÃÂÃÂ. â. I. - 2008, ÃÂ. 303âÂÂ305.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂàþÃÂÃÂÃÂþòð ÃÂõÃÂàø ðÃÂÃÂ
õþðÃÂÃÂÃÂþýþüøÃÂ. ASTROKAZAN - 2009. REPORTS. (üðÃÂõÃÂøðûàúþýÃÂõÃÂõýÃÂøø). ÃÂð÷ðýÃÂ: ÃÂÃÂã, 2009, ÃÂÃÂÃÂ. 8âÂÂ12.
- Grigoriev S.A., Vasina J.V. Megaliths of the Vera Island in the Southern Urals. In: British archaeological report. International series 2123. Monumental questions: prehistoric megaliths, mounds and enclosures. Oxford, 2010, pp. 179âÂÂ185.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á. ÃÂ. ÃÂõóðûøÃÂàãÃÂðûð ò ÃÂòõÃÂõ øýôþõòÃÂþÿõùÃÂúþù ÿÃÂþñûõüà// ÃÂýôþõòÃÂþÿõùÃÂúðàøÃÂÃÂþÃÂøàò ÃÂòõÃÂõ ýþòÃÂÃÂ
øÃÂÃÂûõôþòðýøù. ÃÂþÃÂúòð: ø÷ôðÃÂõûÃÂÃÂÃÂòþ ÃÂÃÂÃÂã, 2010, ÃÂ. 195âÂÂ204.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á.ÃÂ. ÃÂðüõýýÃÂõ þÃÂÃÂôøàÿþÃÂõûõýøàÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂþò ÃÂõÃÂà4 // çõûÃÂñøýÃÂúøù óÃÂüðýøÃÂðÃÂøù. 2010. No. 10. á. 147âÂÂ156.
- ÃÂÃÂøóþÃÂÃÂõò á. ÃÂ. ÃÂÃÂøÃÂþôýÃÂõ úðÃÂðÃÂÃÂÃÂþÃÂàò ÃÂýõþûøÃÂõ ýð ãÃÂðûõ ôþúûðô ýð ãÃÂá // XVIII ãÃÂðûÃÂÃÂúþõ ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúþõ ÃÂþòõÃÂðýøõ: úÃÂûÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂýÃÂõ þñûðÃÂÃÂø, ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúøõ úÃÂûÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂ, ÃÂ
ÃÂþýþûþóøÃÂ. ãÃÂð, 2010, ÃÂ. 69âÂÂ71.
- ÃÂþûÃÂúþòð ÃÂ.ÃÂ. àðÃÂúþÿúø ðûûõø üõýóøÃÂþò çõúð 2 ò ÃÂø÷øûÃÂÃÂúþü ÃÂðùþýõ çõûÃÂñøýÃÂúþù þñûðÃÂÃÂø ò 2009 ó. // XVIII ãÃÂðûÃÂÃÂúþõ ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúþõ ÃÂþòõÃÂðýøõ: úÃÂûÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂýÃÂõ þñûðÃÂÃÂø, ðÃÂÃÂ
õþûþóøÃÂõÃÂúøõ úÃÂûÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂÃÂ, ÃÂ
ÃÂþýþûþóøÃÂ. ãÃÂð, 2010, ÃÂ. 357âÂÂ359.