Duke Ellington and his Famous Orchestra recorded the song in New York City on December 1, 1944, with vocal by Joya Sherrill. It was released as RCA Victor 20âÂÂ1618 in early 1945 on a 78rpm record backing "Don't You Know I Care". The recording went to No. 4 on the Harlem Hit Parade chart in Billboard and reached No. 6 on the pop chart.
Harry James and his Orchestra for Columbia Records, with lead vocals by Kitty Kallen, recorded the song on November 21, 1944, and reached No. 1 for two weeks in January 1945. James' version also reached No. 7 on Billboards Second Annual High School Survey in 1945.