Charles Gates Dempsey (March 11, 1937 â February 22, 2022) was an American art historian of the Italian Renaissance and Baroque. A longtime professor at Johns Hopkins University, he was known for reorienting Renaissance studies toward vernacular cultureâÂÂfestivals, masking, and poeticsâÂÂalongside style and iconography. His books include The Portrayal of Love (1992), Inventing the Renaissance Putto (2001), and The Early Renaissance and Vernacular Culture (2012). With Elizabeth Cropper he co-authored Nicolas Poussin: Friendship and the Love of Painting (1996), which won both the Jan Mitchell Prize and the College Art AssociationâÂÂs Charles Rufus Morey Book Award.
Early life and education
Dempsey was born in Providence, Rhode Island, on March 11, 1937. He received a BA from Swarthmore College (1959) and an MFA (1962) and PhD (1963) from Princeton University, where he studied with Erwin Panofsky.
Career
From 1963 to 1965 Dempsey was a Rome Prize Fellow in the History of Art at the American Academy in Rome. He taught at Bryn Mawr College from 1965 to 1980, serving as department chair (1975âÂÂ1980), and then joined Johns Hopkins University in 1980 as professor of Italian Renaissance and Baroque art; he chaired the department (1989âÂÂ1995) and directed studies at the universityâÂÂs Center for Italian Studies at Villa Spelman in Florence. He retired as professor emeritus in 2007.
At Hopkins he advised multiple generations of scholars. Colleagues highlighted his breadthâÂÂfrom pagan mythology and Renaissance putti to the Carracci, Caravaggio, Poussin, and BoschâÂÂand his insistence on rigorous, textually grounded argument. He helped reshape the fieldâÂÂs engagement with the Bolognese writer Carlo Cesare Malvasia and seventeenth-century art writing. Dempsey also maintained long ties to HarvardâÂÂs Villa I Tatti: he delivered the Bernard Berenson Lectures later published as The Early Renaissance and Vernacular Culture, and is listed among I Tatti fellows (VIT âÂÂ74).
Scholarship and contributions
DempseyâÂÂs work emphasized the interaction of classical form with local, vernacular practices and literary poetics. The Portrayal of Love situated BotticelliâÂÂs Primavera within Laurentian poetry; Inventing the Renaissance Putto traced the spiritello from demonology to civic spectacle; and The Early Renaissance and Vernacular Culture synthesized these concerns in a set of Bernard Berenson Lectures delivered at Villa I Tatti. Reviews in leading journals recognized these books for their originality and influence.
With Elizabeth Cropper he co-wrote Nicolas Poussin: Friendship and the Love of Painting (1996), a widely reviewed study that linked PoussinâÂÂs theory and practice to a network of friendships and texts; the book won the 1997 Jan Mitchell Prize and the 1998 Charles Rufus Morey Book Award.
Legacy and influence
Peers and students credit Dempsey with redirecting aspects of Renaissance studies away from purely Neoplatonic frames toward vernacular culture, festival, masking, and poetics, while remaining attentive to style and iconography. The breadth of his scholarshipâÂÂranging from Botticelli and the spiritelli to the Carracci, Caravaggio, Poussin, and BoschâÂÂwas frequently noted in memorial tributes and reviews. A 2012 Festschrift, Gifts in Return: Essays in Honour of Charles Dempsey, gathered contributions from leading historians of Italian art, reflecting his impact across generations of scholarship and teaching. He also served the field institutionally, including appointment to the National Gallery of ArtâÂÂs Center for Advanced Study in the Visual Arts (CASVA) Board of Advisors in 1985.
Honors
Dempsey received the Christian R. & Mary F. Lindback Foundation Award for Distinguished Teaching (Bryn Mawr), the College Art AssociationâÂÂs A. Kingsley Porter Prize (for his 1968 Art Bulletin article âÂÂEt nos cedamus amoriâÂÂ), and election to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences (1993) and the American Philosophical Society (1998). He held a fellowship at Villa I Tatti (Harvard University Center for Italian Renaissance Studies) in 1974. In 2019 he became a corresponding member of the Slovenian Academy of Sciences and Arts (SAZU).
Works
The list below draws primarily on the bibliography compiled in the 2012 Festschrift.
Books and edited volumes
- Annibale Carracci and the Beginnings of Baroque Style. Glückstadt: J. J. Augustin, 1977; 2nd ed., with new introduction, Florence: Edizioni Cadmo (Villa I Tatti Series 16), 2000.
- La Galerie des Carrache. Paris: Banque de Paris, 1984. (with essay by A. Brejon de Lavargnée; supplementary materials by V. Konig, Ph. Levillain, Ph. Morel, F. Uginet).
- The Portrayal of Love: BotticelliâÂÂs Primavera and Humanist Culture at the Time of Lorenzo the Magnificent. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1992.
- Annibale Carracci: The Farnese Gallery, Rome. New York: George Braziller, 1995. (Simultaneously published in Italian as Annibale Carracci: Palazzo Farnese, Turin: SocietÃÂ Editrice Internazionale, 1995).
- (with Elizabeth Cropper) Nicolas Poussin: Friendship and the Love of Painting. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1996.
- (ed.) Quattrocento Adriatico: Fifteenth-Century Art of the Adriatic Rim. Bologna: Nuova Alfa Editoriale, 1996.
- Inventing the Renaissance Putto. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2001.
- Il Ritratto dellâÂÂAmore: La Primavera di Botticelli e la cultura umanistica al tempo di Lorenzo il Magnifico (Italian translation of The Portrayal of Love with new introduction). Naples: La Stanza delle Scritture, 2007.
- The Early Renaissance and Vernacular Culture (Bernard Berenson Lectures 3). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2012.
Dissertation
- Poussin and the Natural Order. PhD, Princeton University, 1963 (University Microfilms).
Articles and chapters (selected, by decade)
1960s
- âÂÂPoussin and Egypt.â Art Bulletin 45 (1963): 109âÂÂ119.
- âÂÂPoussinâÂÂs Marine Venus at Philadelphia: A Re-Identification Accepted.â Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 28 (1965): 338âÂÂ343.
- âÂÂThe Textual Sources of PoussinâÂÂs Marine Venus in Philadelphia.â Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 29 (1966): 438âÂÂ443.
- âÂÂThe Perception of Nature in PoussinâÂÂs Earlier Works.â Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 29 (1966): 219âÂÂ249.
- âÂÂEuanthes redivivus: RubensâÂÂs Prometheus Bound.â Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 30 (1967): 420âÂÂ425.
- âÂÂMercurius Ver: The Sources of BotticelliâÂÂs Primavera.â Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 31 (1968): 251âÂÂ273.
- âÂÂ'Et nos cedamus amori': Observations on the Farnese Gallery.â The Art Bulletin 50 (1968): 363âÂÂ374. (A. Kingsley Porter Prize.)
- Reviews and notes in Art Bulletin 52 (1970): 324âÂÂ326; Bryn Mawr Alumnae Bulletin (1966âÂÂ67): 67âÂÂ70.
1970s
- âÂÂBotticelliâÂÂs Three Graces.â Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 34 (1971): 326âÂÂ330.
- âÂÂMasaccioâÂÂs Trinity: Altarpiece or Tomb?â Art Bulletin 54 (1972): 279âÂÂ281.
- âÂÂCastiglione at Philadelphia.â The Burlington Magazine 114 (1972): 117âÂÂ120.
- âÂÂTiepolo Etchings at Washington.â The Burlington Magazine 114 (1972): 503âÂÂ507.
- Reviews in Art Bulletin 58 (1976): 129âÂÂ131; 61 (1979): 141âÂÂ144, 323âÂÂ326.
- âÂÂSome Observations on the Education of Artists in Florence and Bologna during the later Sixteenth Century.â Art Bulletin 62 (1980): 552âÂÂ569.
1980s
- âÂÂAnnibal Carrache au Palais Farnèse.â In Le Palais Farnèse, ÃÂcole française de Rome, 1981, I/1: 269âÂÂ311.
- âÂÂAnnibale CarracciâÂÂs Christ and the Canaanite Woman.â The Burlington Magazine 123 (1981): 91âÂÂ95.
- âÂÂMythic Inventions in Counter-Reformation Painting.â In Rome in the Renaissance: The City and the Myth, ed. P. A. Ramsay, Binghamton, NY, 1982, 55âÂÂ75.
- Reviews/essays in The New Criterion (1982âÂÂ83); The Burlington Magazine (1983); Renaissance Quarterly (1984); Times Literary Supplement (1986); Art in America (1986); Renaissance Quarterly (1986).
- âÂÂThe Carracci Postille to VasariâÂÂs Lives.â Art Bulletin 68 (1986): 72âÂÂ76.
- âÂÂMalvasia and the Problem of the Early Raphael and Bologna.â In Raphael before Rome, ed. James Beck, National Gallery of Art, Studies in the History of Art 17 (1986): 57âÂÂ70.
- âÂÂThe Carracci Reform of Painting.â In The Age of Correggio and the Carracci, exh. cat., National Gallery of Art, 1986, 237âÂÂ254 (and Italian trans., Bologna, 1986, 237âÂÂ254).
- âÂÂThe Carracci and the Devout Style in Emilia.â In Emilian Painting of the 16th and Seventeenth Centuries, ed. H. Millon (National Gallery of Art), Bologna, 1987, 75âÂÂ87.
- âÂÂThe State of Research in Italian Painting of the Seventeenth Centuryâ (with Elizabeth Cropper). Art Bulletin 69 (1987): 494âÂÂ509.
- âÂÂRenaissance Hieroglyphic Studies and Gentile BelliniâÂÂs Saint Mark Preaching in Alexandria.â In Hermeticism and the Renaissance, ed. I. Merkel and A. G. Debus, Folger Books, 1988, 342âÂÂ365.
- âÂÂGuido Reni in the Eyes of his Roman Contemporaries.â In Guido Reni 1575âÂÂ1642 (exh. cat.), Los Angeles, 1988, 101âÂÂ118.
- âÂÂFederico Barocci and the Discovery of Pastel.â In Marcia B. Hall (ed.), Color and Technique in Renaissance Painting, Locust Valley, 1988, 55âÂÂ65.
- âÂÂPoussinâÂÂs Sacrament of Confirmation: The Scholarship of Roma sotteranea and Dal PozzoâÂÂs Museum chartaceum.â In Cassiano dal Pozzo: Atti del Seminario Internazionale di Studi, ed. F. Solinas, Rome, 1989, 244âÂÂ261.
- âÂÂThe Carracci Academy.â In Academies of Art between Renaissance and Romanticism, ed. A. W. A. Boschloo et al., The Hague, 1989, 33âÂÂ43.
1990s
- Introduction to Gli scritti dei Carracci: Ludovico, Annibale, Agostino (Villa Spelman Colloquia 2), ed. Giovanna Perini, Bologna, 1990, 9âÂÂ31.
- âÂÂSua cuique mihi meaâ¦â The Burlington Magazine 132 (1990): 490âÂÂ492.
- âÂÂNational Expression in Italian Sixteenth-century Art: Problems of the Past and Present.â In Nationalism in the Visual Arts, ed. R. Etlin, National Gallery of Art, Studies in the History of Art 29 (1991): 15âÂÂ24.
- âÂÂThe Most Difficult Iconographical Problem in the World: DomenichinoâÂÂs Madonna of the Rosary.â In Il luogo ed il ruolo della cittàdi Bologna, ed. G. Perini, 1992, 341âÂÂ355.
- âÂÂMavors armipotens: The Poetics of Self-representation in PoussinâÂÂs Mars and Venus.â In Der Künstler über sich in seinem Werk, ed. M. Winner, 1992, 435âÂÂ452.
- âÂÂIdealism and Naturalism in Rome around 1600.â In Il classicismo, Bologna, 1993, 233âÂÂ243.
- âÂÂLorenzoâÂÂs Ombra.â In Lorenzo il Magnifico e il suo mondo, ed. G. A. Garfagnini, Florence, 1994, 341âÂÂ355.
- âÂÂSujets et thèmes dans la peinture de Poussin.â In P. Rosenberg and L.-A. Prat, Nicolas Poussin 1594âÂÂ1665, Paris, 1994, 88âÂÂ92.
- Reviews in TLS (1995) and Renaissance Quarterly 48 (1995): 422âÂÂ424.
- âÂÂDonatelloâÂÂs Spiritelli.â In Ars naturam adiuvans (Festschrift for Matthias Winner, ed. V. Von Flemming et al.), 1996, 50âÂÂ61.
- âÂÂMort en Arcadie: Les derniers tableaux de Poussin.â In Nicolas Poussin⦠(Musée du Louvre), 1996, 50âÂÂ61.
- âÂÂLâÂÂimpression de merveilleux àla galerie du palais Farnèse.â (Louvre colloque), 1996, 195âÂÂ221.
- âÂÂThe 1998 Josephine Waters Bennett Lecture: Portraits and Masksâ¦â Renaissance Quarterly 52 (1999): 1âÂÂ42.
- âÂÂNiccolò di GiovanniâÂÂs Spiritelli in Trogir.â In Festschrift for Ksenijo Rozman, Ljubljana, 1999, 43âÂÂ55.
- âÂÂPoussinâÂÂs Ecstasy of St. Paul: Charles Le BrunâÂÂs âÂÂOver-InterpretationâÂÂ.â In Commemorating Poussin, ed. K. Scott and G. Warwick, Cambridge, 1999, 114âÂÂ133.
2000s
- âÂÂNicolas Poussin between Italy and France: PoussinâÂÂs Death of Germanicus.â In LâÂÂEuropa e lâÂÂarte italiana, ed. M. Seidel, Florence, 2000, 320âÂÂ335.
- âÂÂ'Le vite deâ pittori...' di Giovan Pietro Bellori.â (2000), 99âÂÂ103; âÂÂI Carracci a Palazzo Farneseâ¦,â plus catalogue entries, in LâÂÂIdea del Bello, ed. E. Borea et al., Rome, 2000.
- âÂÂRenaissance Hieroglyphic Studies: An Overview.â In Interpretation and Allegory, ed. J. Whitman, Leiden, 2000, 365âÂÂ378.
- Reviews: Musacchio (2001); Fumaroli (2002); Olson (2002).
- âÂÂCaravaggio e i due stili naturalistici: Speculare contro Macolare.â In Caravaggio nel IV centenario, ed. C. Volpi, 2002, 185âÂÂ196.
- Review: Rosand, Myths of Venice, Renaissance Quarterly 56 (2003): 454âÂÂ456.
- âÂÂLove and the Figure of the Nymph in BotticelliâÂÂs Art.â (2003); Italian version 2004. In Botticelli from Lorenzo the Magnificent to Savonarola, ed. D. Arasse et al., 25âÂÂ38.
- Intro., Drawing Relationships in Northern Italian Renaissance Art, ed. G. Periti, Aldershot, 2004, 1âÂÂ9.
- âÂÂSicut in utrem aquas maris: Jerome BoschâÂÂs Prolegomenon to the Garden of Earthly Delights.â MLN 119 (Italian Issue Suppl., 2004): 246âÂÂ270.
- âÂÂGiuliano di Piero deâ Medici.â In The Folio Society Book of the 100 Greatest Portraits (2004), 36âÂÂ37.
- âÂÂHistoria and Anachronism in Renaissance Art.â Art Bulletin 87 (2005): 416âÂÂ421.
- Reviews: Kasl (2005); âÂÂHommage àDaniel Arasseâ (2005); âÂÂBaccio BaldiniâÂÂs Sibyls and AlbumasarâÂÂs Introductorium maius.â (2006).
- âÂÂCaravaggio and the Two Naturalist Styles: Specular versus Macular.â In Warwick (ed.), Caravaggio: Realism, Rebellion, Reception (2006), 91âÂÂ100.
- Reprint: âÂÂThe Carracci and the Devout Style in Emilia.â In Cole (ed.), Sixteenth-Century Italian Art (2006), 388âÂÂ402.
- Reviews: Unglaub; Hipp (2007); Falomir (2007).
- âÂÂPainting in Bologna from the Carracci to Crespi.â In Captured Emotions (Getty, 2008), 1âÂÂ13.
- Preface to Le âÂÂStanzeâ di Guido Reni, ed. B. Bohn, Uffizi, 2008, xiâÂÂxiv.
- âÂÂThe Importance of Vernacular Style in Renaissance Art: The Invention of Simone MartiniâÂÂs Maestàâ¦â In Cropper (ed.), Dialogues in Art History, National Gallery of Art (2009), 189âÂÂ205.
- âÂÂDisegno and Logos, Paragone and Academy.â In The Accademia Seminars, ed. P. M. Lukehart, National Gallery of Art, 2009, 43âÂÂ53.
2010s
- Review: Stuart Lingo, Federico Barocci (Art Bulletin 92.3, 2010): 251âÂÂ256.
- âÂÂNicolas Poussin et lâÂÂinvention de lâÂÂidylle mythologique.â In Cohn (ed.), Daniel Arasse: historien de lâÂÂart (2010), 121âÂÂ132.
- âÂÂThe PainterâÂÂs Arcadia.â In Gauguin, Cézanne, MatisseâÂÂArcadia 1900, exh. cat., PMA, New Haven, 2012, 125âÂÂ141.
- âÂÂPoussin, Duquesnoy, and the Greek Style.â In Di Cosmo & Fatticcioni (eds.), Le componenti del Classicismo secentesco (2013), 159âÂÂ167.
- âÂÂMalvasiaâÂÂs Il Claustro di S. Michele in Bosco (Bologna, 1694).â In Anselmi et al. (eds.), Bologna: Cultural Crossroads⦠(2013), 107âÂÂ112.
- Review: Christophe Poncet, La scelta di Lorenzo (Renaissance Quarterly 66.3, 2013): 977âÂÂ978.
- âÂÂRaphaelâÂÂs Legacy in Italy circa 1600.â In Falomir (ed.), Late Raphael (Prado, 2013), 156âÂÂ159.
- Review: Francisco de Hollanda, On Antique Painting (The Burlington Magazine 156, 2014): 537.
- Review: David Young Kim, The Traveling Artist in the Italian Renaissance (The Burlington Magazine 158, 2016): 39âÂÂ40.
Death
Dempsey died of a heart attack in Washington, D.C., on February 22, 2022. Obituaries from Johns Hopkins, the Renaissance Society of America, and The New York Times site noted his influence as a scholar, teacher, and mentor.
Further reading
- Schlitt, Melinda Wilcox (ed.). Gifts in Return: Essays in Honour of Charles Dempsey. Toronto: Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies, 2012. ISBN 978-0-7727-2130-3. Publisher page
- Dempsey, Charles. Il Ritratto dellâÂÂAmore: La Primavera di Botticelli e la cultura umanistica al tempo di Lorenzo il Magnifico. Naples: La Stanza delle Scritture, 2007. ISBN 8889254025. Catalog
- La Galerie des Carrache au Palais Farnèse. Paris: Banque Nationale de Paris / ÃÂcole française de Rome, 1983. (Texts by Arnaud Brejon de Lavergnée, Charles Dempsey, Verena König, et al.) National Library of Australia record
External links
References