The 2021 New York City FC season was the club's seventh season of competition and its seventh in the top tier of American soccer, Major League Soccer. New York City FC usually played its home games at Yankee Stadium in the New York City borough of The Bronx. Like the 2020 MLS season, the club also played several of their home games at Red Bull Arena in Harrison, New Jersey due to scheduling conflicts with Yankee Stadium and its backup stadium, Citi Field. New York City FC won the clubs' first MLS Cup title by defeating the Portland Timbers 2âÂÂ4 in penalty shoot-outs with a 1âÂÂ1 score before going into extra time, in which neither of the teams scored.
In addition to the MLS season, the club also competed in the Leagues Cup for the first time, finishing up in the quarter-finals after losing to UNAM in a penalty shoot-out.
On July 20, US Soccer announced that the tournament would be cancelled for 2021 and would resume in 2022.
|- ! colspan=14 style=background:#dcdcdc; text-align:center|Goalkeepers
|- ! colspan=14 style=background:#dcdcdc; text-align:center|Defenders
|- ! colspan=14 style=background:#dcdcdc; text-align:center|Midfielders
|- ! colspan=14 style=background:#dcdcdc; text-align:center|Forwards
|-