The 1873 Newfoundland general election was held on November 8, 1873 to elect members of the 11th General Assembly of Newfoundland in the Colony of Newfoundland. The Anti-Confederates led by Charles Fox Bennett formed the government; a "new" Conservative party led by Frederick Carter formed the opposition.
|- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=3|St. John's East || |John Dearin<br>1,177<br>26.70% | |Ambrose Shea<br>803<br>18.21% || |William Walshâ |- || |Robert Parsons Sr.<br>1,109<br>25.15% |rowspan=2| |rowspan=2|John Maher<br>254<br>5.76% || |James Jordanâ |- || |Robert Kent<br>1,066<br>24.18% || |Robert Parsons Sr. |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=3|St. John's West || |Lewis Tessier<br>1,030<br>31.95% |rowspan=3| |rowspan=3|Lawrence Barron<br>489<br>15.17% || |Peter Brennanâ |- || |Maurice Fenelon<br>897<br>27.82% || |Maurice Fenelon |- || |Patrick Scott<br>808<br>25.06% || |Lewis Tessier |-
|- |bgcolor=whitesmoke|Bay de Verde | | || |James Rogerson<br>Won by acclamation || |James Rogerson |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke|Carbonear | | || |John Rorke<br>Won by acclamation || |John Rorke |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=2|Harbour Grace |rowspan=2| |rowspan=2|? Parsons<br>420<br>17.61% || |William Wood<br>984<br>41.26% || |John Munnâ |- || |Frederick Carter<br>981<br>41.13% || |William Greenâ |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=2|Harbour Main || |Joseph Little<br>763<br>47.33% |rowspan=2| |rowspan=2|Charles Furey<br>290<br>17.99% || |Joseph Little |- || |Patrick Nowlan<br>559<br>34.68% || |John Kennedyâ |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=2|Port de Grave || |John Bartlett | |George Gushue || |James Woodsâ |-
|- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=2|Ferryland || |Thomas Glen<br>678<br>44.75% |rowspan=2| |rowspan=2|Edward Shea<br>171<br>11.29% || |Thomas Glen |- || |Richard Raftus<br>666<br>43.96% || |Thomas Badcockâ |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=3|Placentia and St. Mary's || |Henry Renouf<br>739<br>31.43% |rowspan=3| |rowspan=3|Thomas Rielley<br>151<br>6.42% || |Charles Fox Bennett |- || |James Collins<br>735<br>31.26% || |Robert Parsons Jr.â |- || |Charles Fox Bennett<br>726<br>30.88% || |Henry Renouf
|- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=3|Bonavista Bay | |James Noonan || |Charles Bowring<br> || |James Noonan |- | |William Barnes || |A. J. W. McNeilly<br> || |William Barnes |- | |Francis Winton || |John Burton || |Francis Winton |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=3|Trinity Bay | |Robert Pinsent<br>590<br>13.28% || |John Steer<br>1,141<br>25.68% || |Stephen Rendellâ |- |rowspan=2| |rowspan=2|Stephen March<br>519<br>11.68% || |John Warren<br>1,102<br>24.80% || |Alexander Grahamâ |- || |William Whiteway<br>1,091<br>24.56% || |John Warren |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=3|Twillingate and Fogo || |Charles Duder<br>758<br>17.49% || |Frederick Carter<br>751<br>17.32% || |Charles Duder |- || |Smith McKay<br>746<br>17.21% | |Stephen Knight<br>700<br>16.15% || |Smith McKay |- | |James Rolls<br>700<br>16.15% | |? Windsor<br>680<br>15.69% || |New seat
|- |bgcolor=whitesmoke|Burgeo and LaPoile | | || |Prescott Emerson<br>Won by acclamation || |Prescott Emerson |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke rowspan=2|Burin | | || |James Winter<br>Won by acclamation || |Frederick Carterâ¡<br><small>(Ran in Harbour Grace and Twillingate and Fogo)</small> |- | | || |Charles Ayre<br>Won by acclamation || |Edward Evansâ |- |bgcolor=whitesmoke|Fortune Bay || |Thomas Bennett<br>Won by acclamation | | || |Thomas Bennett